Steve Hanson's Blog

Steve Hanson is the founder and editor of Uppity Wisconsin. He is also a web developer in his spare time.

Rudy Giuliani - Whatta dunce

I take back everything I've said in the last few days about having mixed feelings about the Democratic Convention. I've been watching the Republican Convention, and am currently watching Giuliani's keynote speech.  I feel much better about the Democratic Convention now.

I don't know where to start. From his attacks on Obama for voting present (which I'll grant you is different from McCain - who generally just doesn't show up for any vote that he's not interested in) to his somewhat contorted  notion that being a senator and a community organizer isn't "real experience" but that being a mayor of a city of 7,000 is, to -- well, the mind reels.  Obviously Giuliani has never tried to be a community organizer.

Why can't he ever ever ever think of anything that isn't related to 9/11?  Now he's finding the Democrats negligent for not talking about 9/11 during their convention.  Golly - that really was quite a while ago.  You'd kind of think that it might be reasonable to talk about - um - the present.  

What is it with this business of McCain being a  POW.  I don't take that lightly - my dad was a POW in WWII and I always had a great respect for the fact that that was one of the turning points of his life, and changed him forever.  But I never would have considered that to be a reason to make him president. And I'm sure he knew that as well.  

The general tenor of all of this is to dwell on the past, to dwell on how important it is to "win" in Iraq, and to imply that governorship and being a mayor are the only kinds of experience that count - where the hell does that leave McCain?  I understand that his role here is to bring out the red meat to dangle in front of the party loyalists - but in general these speeches strike me as desperate attempts to defend a lot of bad decisions that have had bad results, and to make it look like they are the only defenders of freedom in the world.  I can't imagine that this display is playing very well outside of the confines of the convention. 

I now must go wash out my ears.  If this sort of claptrap is the presumed future of our country, let's fight it tooth and nail.

GIuliani has blathered on so long that they've needed to cancel the video introducing Sarah Palin - and I have to say that after listening to Giuliani speak, I'm actually looking forward to this - much as I think she's a totally inappropriate candidate, I assume she's going to at least act in a sane manner.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

There is a temptation to get

There is a temptation to get on Google and disect the speech for all its lies line by line like Al Franken did to Ann Coulter using Nexes in his book. But the author would be a bored as the reader.

Because winning the GOP

Because winning the GOP nomination, and eventually the Presidency, is about compromise and coalition-building. And Huckabee, while benefiting from his “army” of ardent evangelical and values voters, hasn’t done anything to endear himself to the other factions of the conservative base (fiscal and national security conservatives) or even independents.

This is a view I’m not alone on, either, given this from a Christian leader quoted at the tail end of a New York Times article on Huckabee:

...some Christian conservatives say that no matter the energy at their grass roots, the animosity of their secular allies may well doom his campaign.

Richard Land, the top public policy official of the Southern Baptist Convention, argued that just as small-government and foreign-policy conservatives could not win a primary without evangelicals, “I don’t think evangelicals can win without most of the rest of those coalitions.”

Mr. Land is right. Huckabee can’t win without fiscal conservatives and independents on board, and Huck’s appeal among these factions is low. So low, that even if his “army” does manage to ram-rod him through the primaries he won’t have much of a chance of winning the general election.

What’s more, Huckabee has no business even running as a conservative. Certainly he’s conservative on social issues, but it’s worth noting that the founders of the conservative movement were concerned with limiting the power and scope of government to reasonable levels. Social issues were a cause secondary.

Huckabee, by putting social issues first and paying only lip service to the ideals of fiscal conservatism, is essentially trying to hijack a political movement that never belonged to him in the first place.

If we in the GOP want to win come November, we have to nominate a consensus candidate who appeals to all factions within the party. That’s not Giuliani with his liberal social views. It could have been Romney, except that Mitt has changed so many of his core beliefs just prior to the primary season that he comes off as insincere. McCain has abandoned the conservative base on a lot of high-profile issues like campaign finance, judicial appointments and illegal immigration and some comes off as untrustworthy as Romney. So who is left?

Fred Thompson, I think, though admittedly I’ve been a Thompson supporter since day one and am probably not very objective. I think Thompson is the “consensus candidate” capable of the broadest amount of appeal among Republicans and independents. His only knock has been that many don’t feel he’s “electable,” but as I’ve noted before if the number of people who say they would like to see Thompson win the nomination but don’t think he can would just come out and support him he’d win in a landslide.

_________________
Submited by : Libros Gratis

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.